What's the best method to attach a shackle to your halyard?

Currently, all mine are spliced on - which I haven't learned to do yet. However, I can tie a reasonable bowline - or even a Palomar. Which is stronger - knot or splice? (I know which is cheaper!)

Bill Balme

Hi David,
Thanks for coming in on this.

That is an interesting knot that I was unaware of and I will keep it in mind and give it some practice when I get a chance. I especially like that reports indicate that it is more more secure with HM lines. I am also aware of the EStar (developed and tested by Evans Starzinger) which is also good for HM lines but seems a bit bulky for halyards although I have not used it in that context.

My best, Dick Stevenson, s/v Alchemy